5 Best Composting vs Incinerating Toilets for Small Spaces That Save Every Inch

Living in a tiny home, RV, or boat doesn’t mean sacrificing modern bathroom comforts. Composting and incinerating toilets offer sustainable solutions for small spaces where traditional plumbing isn’t practical or available. These innovative bathroom fixtures can transform your off-grid living experience while being environmentally friendly.

Choosing between composting and incinerating models depends on your specific needs, available space, and environmental priorities. Composting toilets break down waste naturally without water, while incinerating options use electricity or gas to reduce waste to sterile ash. We’ve researched and compared the top options to help you make the best choice for your compact living situation.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Composting vs. Incinerating Toilets: Understanding the Differences

When selecting the ideal toilet for your small space, it’s crucial to understand how each system operates and the benefits they provide. Let’s examine the key differences between composting and incinerating toilets to help you make an informed decision.

How Composting Toilets Work

Composting toilets transform human waste into usable compost through natural decomposition. They separate liquid and solid waste, with solids entering a chamber containing peat moss, coconut coir, or sawdust. Aerobic bacteria break down the waste over time, reducing volume by up to 90%. Most models include ventilation systems to eliminate odors and accelerate evaporation. These toilets require no water or chemicals, making them ideal for off-grid applications where water conservation is essential.

How Incinerating Toilets Work

Incinerating toilets use high heat (1000-1200°F) to burn waste into sterile ash. After each use, you press a button that activates an electric heating element or propane burner. The incineration process typically takes 15-20 minutes, reducing waste to about a tablespoon of ash per use. These systems require no water and connect to standard household electricity or propane tanks. Most units feature catalytic converters that eliminate smoke and odors, venting harmless gases through a small pipe to the exterior.

Key Factors for Small Space Applications

When choosing between these systems for small spaces, consider power requirements first—incinerating toilets need reliable electricity (typically 110-220V) or propane, while composting toilets operate without power or with minimal battery fans. Space constraints matter too; composting units typically have larger footprints but shorter heights, while incinerating models have smaller footprints but require vertical clearance. Maintenance differs significantly: composting toilets need weekly mixing and emptying every 3-6 weeks, while incinerating units require only occasional ash removal but more frequent filter replacements.

Nature’s Head Self-Contained Composting Toilet: Best Overall Space-Saver

Nature’s Head composting toilet consistently ranks as the top choice for small spaces due to its compact design and reliable performance. This self-contained unit offers the perfect balance of functionality and space efficiency for tiny homes, boats, and RVs.

Key Features and Benefits

The Nature’s Head toilet measures just 19.8″ wide, 20.5″ deep, and 20.5″ high, making it ideal for tight spaces. It features a spider handle design for easy mixing, an integrated fan for odor control, and completely separates liquid and solid waste. You’ll appreciate its durable construction with stainless steel hardware that withstands marine environments. The molded seat offers standard-sized comfort despite the compact footprint.

Installation Requirements

Installation requires minimal space—you’ll need about 1.5″ of clearance on each side and sufficient room for the lid to open fully. The unit needs a 12V power source for the fan and a 1.5″ diameter vent hole for proper ventilation. No water connection is necessary, allowing for flexible placement. The toilet should be secured to a solid floor using the included brackets to prevent movement during use or travel.

Maintenance Considerations

You’ll need to empty the liquid tank every 3-5 days depending on usage, while the solid waste compartment typically requires emptying every 4-6 weeks for two people. Maintenance involves adding coco coir or peat moss after each solid waste deposit. The fan runs continuously to eliminate odors but only uses 1.7 watts of power. Regular cleaning with vinegar solution keeps the unit sanitary without harmful chemicals that could disrupt the composting process.

Villa Clivus Multrum: Best High-End Composting Option

If you’re looking for a premium composting solution that combines luxury with sustainability, the Villa Clivus Multrum stands out as the ultimate high-end option for small spaces.

Space-Efficient Design Elements

The Villa Clivus Multrum maximizes functionality in a surprisingly compact footprint of just 33″ wide and 54″ deep. Its vertical design takes advantage of height rather than floor space, making it ideal for tiny homes with lofted areas. The toilet features a ceramic bowl connected to a separate composting chamber, creating a familiar bathroom experience while saving valuable square footage in your limited living area.

Performance in Limited Areas

In confined spaces, the Villa Clivus Multrum excels with its advanced ventilation system that eliminates odors completely without requiring additional room for air circulation. The three-chamber separation system processes waste more efficiently than standard composting toilets, reducing emptying frequency to just 2-3 times annually even with daily use. This performance advantage is crucial when maintenance access is limited in tight quarters.

Long-Term Value Proposition

Though priced at $4,200-$5,800, the Villa Clivus Multrum offers exceptional longevity with its stainless steel components carrying a 25-year warranty. The system’s design significantly reduces operating costs by consuming 90% less water than conventional toilets and eliminating the need for chemicals or additives. For permanent small dwellings, this premium toilet pays for itself within 8-10 years through utility savings and minimal maintenance requirements.

EcoJohn WC-5: Top Incinerating Toilet for Tiny Homes

The EcoJohn WC-5 stands out as the premier incinerating toilet solution specifically designed for tiny homes and other compact living spaces. Its sleek design and powerful incineration capabilities make it an excellent choice for those wanting a waterless, low-maintenance toilet system.

Power Requirements and Consumption

The EcoJohn WC-5 operates on standard 110V electricity, drawing approximately 1,500 watts during its incineration cycle. You’ll need to budget about $1-2 per cycle in electricity costs, depending on your local rates. The unit includes a smart power management system that minimizes consumption during standby periods, making it more efficient than older incinerating models. For off-grid tiny homes, this toilet works well with a solar setup that includes a sufficient battery bank and inverter.

Ventilation Needs

You’ll need to install a dedicated 3-inch stainless steel vent pipe that extends at least 2 feet above your roof line for the EcoJohn WC-5. The system includes a small internal fan that creates negative pressure to eliminate odors and expel combustion gases. The manufacturer recommends maintaining at least 24 inches of clearance from windows, doors, or air intakes to prevent exhaust recirculation. Unlike composting toilets, the ventilation requirements are non-negotiable for safety and proper function.

Waste Processing Capacity

The EcoJohn WC-5 can handle up to 8-10 uses before running an incineration cycle, making it suitable for households with 2-4 people. Each cycle reduces waste to approximately one tablespoon of sterile ash, which you’ll only need to empty every 3-4 weeks with regular use. The incineration process takes about 60-90 minutes to complete, during which time the toilet remains available for liquid waste but not solid waste. For tiny homes with occasional guests, the system easily accommodates temporary increases in usage.

Sun-Mar Excel: Best Composting Toilet for Off-Grid Living

For those seeking true freedom from the grid while maintaining modern comforts, the Sun-Mar Excel composting toilet stands out as the superior choice for self-sufficient living arrangements.

Non-Electric Operation Benefits

The Sun-Mar Excel operates completely without electricity, making it ideal for off-grid cabins and remote tiny homes. You’ll never worry about power outages affecting bathroom functionality. Its gravity-fed design uses natural airflow and a patented bio-drum to efficiently break down waste without fans or heaters. This zero-energy solution saves approximately $50-75 annually in electricity costs compared to electric composting models.

Compact Footprint Advantages

Despite its robust capacity, the Sun-Mar Excel maintains a surprisingly modest footprint of just 22.5″ wide by 33″ deep. Its vertical design maximizes available floor space while the overall height of 30″ allows for installation in areas with limited headroom. The toilet’s built-in evaporating chamber eliminates the need for separate liquid collection containers, streamlining your bathroom layout and saving precious square footage in your small living space.

Handling Capacity for Multiple Users

The Sun-Mar Excel effortlessly supports continuous use by 2-3 full-time residents or 5-7 weekend users. Its large composting chamber can process up to 8 uses daily without compromising performance. The rotating bio-drum technology accelerates decomposition, allowing you to go 4-6 weeks between emptying cycles—significantly longer than most compact composting toilets. This higher capacity makes it perfect for small families or tiny homes that frequently host guests.

Incinolet TR-3: Most Efficient Incinerating System

The Incinolet TR-3 stands out as a powerhouse among incinerating toilets for those living in compact spaces. This American-made unit offers remarkable efficiency in a surprisingly small package.

Heat Management in Confined Spaces

The Incinolet TR-3 features advanced thermal insulation that keeps exterior temperatures safe while reaching the 1,400°F needed for complete incineration. Its double-walled design creates an air gap that reduces heat transfer to surrounding surfaces, making it ideal for installation in tight bathroom corners. You’ll only need 1″ of clearance around the unit—a crucial advantage when every inch counts in your tiny home or boat.

Odor Control Effectiveness

You’ll appreciate the TR-3’s sophisticated odor management system that operates on two fronts. During use, a small exhaust fan creates negative pressure to eliminate bathroom odors. During incineration, gases pass through a platinum catalyst that neutralizes potential smells before they exit through the vent pipe. This system effectively handles up to 4-5 daily uses without lingering odors, outperforming many competing models in tight living quarters.

Maintenance Simplicity

Maintaining the TR-3 couldn’t be simpler—it produces just a tablespoon of sterile ash per use that needs emptying roughly every 3-4 weeks for a couple. The self-cleaning cycle eliminates the need for chemical cleaners, while the removable bowl liner prevents waste contact with the main chamber. When replacement is needed, the heating element can be swapped out in under 30 minutes with basic tools, avoiding costly service calls for off-grid dwellers.

Choosing the Right Toilet for Your Small Space Needs

Whether you’re outfitting a tiny home boat or RV the right toilet solution makes all the difference in your comfort and sustainability. Each option we’ve reviewed offers unique advantages depending on your specific needs.

Consider your power availability space constraints and maintenance preferences when making your choice. Composting options like the Nature’s Head and Sun-Mar Excel provide excellent off-grid capabilities while incinerating models like the EcoJohn WC-5 and Incinolet TR-3 offer minimal maintenance with higher power requirements.

Your small space doesn’t mean sacrificing modern comforts. These innovative toilet solutions prove you can live sustainably without compromise. Choose the system that best aligns with your lifestyle and enjoy the freedom that comes with an efficient reliable bathroom solution tailored to your compact living space.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do composting toilets work in tiny spaces?

Composting toilets break down human waste naturally without water. They separate liquid and solid waste, using materials like peat moss or sawdust to aid decomposition. These toilets require no plumbing or chemicals, making them perfect for off-grid living in tiny homes, RVs, or boats. The end product is usable compost, and most models include ventilation systems to eliminate odors.

What power requirements do incinerating toilets have?

Incinerating toilets typically require electricity (110V or 220V) or propane gas to function. They use approximately 1,500 watts during incineration cycles, with an estimated cost of $1-2 per cycle. Most models need a dedicated circuit due to their power demands. Unlike composting toilets, they cannot operate off-grid unless you have a robust solar setup or generator system.

How often do I need to empty a composting toilet?

Emptying frequency depends on the model and usage. Smaller units like the Nature’s Head require emptying the solid waste compartment every 4-6 weeks for two people with regular use. Liquid tanks typically need emptying every 2-4 days. Larger units like the Villa Clivus Multrum may only need emptying 2-3 times per year. Regular maintenance ensures optimal performance and odor control.

What maintenance do incinerating toilets require?

Incinerating toilets require less frequent maintenance than composting models but need more specialized care. You’ll need to empty the ash drawer every 20-30 uses (roughly every 3-4 weeks for an average household). Filter replacements are necessary every 3-6 months. The heating elements and exhaust systems should be inspected annually. Some models require periodic cleaning of sensors and vents.

Are composting toilets odor-free?

When properly maintained, composting toilets produce minimal to no odor. Most models feature built-in ventilation fans that direct air outside through a vent pipe. Regular addition of cover material (like coconut coir or peat moss) after each use helps absorb moisture and control odors. Proper separation of liquid and solid waste is essential, as improper separation is the primary cause of odor issues.

How much space do I need for a composting toilet installation?

Composting toilets generally require more floor space but less height than traditional toilets. The Nature’s Head measures 19.8″ wide, 20.5″ deep, and 20.5″ high, making it compact for tiny spaces. Larger models like the Sun-Mar Excel need about 22.5″ × 33″ of floor space. Always account for ventilation requirements—most units need a 2″ vent pipe running to the exterior of your dwelling.

Can incinerating toilets handle multiple users?

Yes, incinerating toilets can handle multiple users, but with limitations. Models like the EcoJohn WC-5 can accommodate 8-10 uses before requiring an incineration cycle, making it suitable for households of 2-4 people. The Incinolet TR-3 can handle 4-5 daily uses efficiently. For larger groups or heavy usage periods, you may need to run more frequent incineration cycles.

Which toilet type is better for off-grid living?

Composting toilets are generally better suited for off-grid living because they require no water and minimal or no electricity. Models like the Sun-Mar Excel operate completely without power using a gravity-fed design. Incinerating toilets, while convenient, demand significant power that may strain off-grid electrical systems. Your choice should align with your available resources and personal preferences regarding maintenance and waste handling.