7 Best Composting Toilets for Water Conservation That Lower Your Footprint
Discover the 7 best composting toilets that save water while converting waste into compost. Perfect for eco-conscious homes, tiny houses, and off-grid living. Sustainable solutions for a greener future!
Looking to reduce your water footprint while contributing to a more sustainable planet? Composting toilets offer an eco-friendly alternative to traditional flush systems, saving thousands of gallons of water annually while transforming waste into valuable compost. These innovative fixtures have come a long way in design and functionality, making them increasingly popular for tiny homes, off-grid cabins, and environmentally conscious households.
Whether you’re preparing for a more sustainable lifestyle or simply want to lower your utility bills, finding the right composting toilet is crucial for success. Today’s models combine efficiency with comfort, eliminating odors and simplifying maintenance in ways that earlier versions couldn’t match. We’ve researched and tested the top options to bring you this comprehensive guide to the seven best composting toilets available right now.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Understanding Composting Toilets: An Eco-Friendly Alternative to Traditional Plumbing
How Composting Toilets Work
Composting toilets operate on a simple biological principle: they separate liquid and solid waste, allowing natural decomposition to occur. These systems use aerobic bacteria to break down human waste into compost material through a controlled process. Unlike traditional toilets that flush waste away with gallons of water, composting toilets contain waste in a chamber where organic material (like coconut coir, peat moss, or sawdust) is added after each use to aid decomposition and eliminate odors. Most models include ventilation systems that remove moisture and prevent smells from escaping into your living space.
Environmental Benefits of Waterless Waste Management
Composting toilets deliver significant environmental advantages beyond water conservation. A typical household can save up to 4,000 gallons of water annually by switching to a composting toilet. They also eliminate the need for sewage infrastructure, reducing groundwater contamination risks and preventing harmful chemicals from entering water systems. The end product—nutrient-rich compost—can safely fertilize non-edible plants when properly processed, completing a natural cycle. By transforming waste into a resource rather than treating it as a disposal problem, composting toilets represent a truly sustainable approach to human waste management.
Nature’s Head Self-Contained Composting Toilet: Best Overall Solution
Nature’s Head composting toilet stands out as the industry leader, combining exceptional quality with user-friendly design. This self-contained unit has earned its reputation as the best overall solution for water conservation in both permanent and mobile installations.
Key Features and Specifications
- Separates liquid and solid waste with an innovative urine diverter system
- Compact dimensions: 20″ high × 17.5″ wide × 20″ deep, ideal for small spaces
- 5-year warranty exceeding industry standards
- Handles up to 90 uses for solids before emptying
- Made of durable, marine-grade stainless steel hardware and robust polyethylene
- Includes built-in spider handle for efficient waste mixing
- Optional 12V fan for improved ventilation and odor control
Installation Requirements and Maintenance Tips
- Requires minimal space: 19-21 inches of clearance from front to back
- Needs a 1.5-2 inch vent hole for proper ventilation
- Can operate on 12V DC (1.7 watts) or 110V AC with adapter
- Empty liquid container approximately every 2-3 days depending on usage
- Add peat moss or coconut coir as bulking material after each solid waste deposit
- Turn spider handle 2-3 rotations after each use to aerate compost
- Clean with vinegar solution rather than harsh chemicals to maintain bacterial activity
Sun-Mar Excel Non-Electric: Best for Off-Grid Living
For true self-sufficiency in remote locations, the Sun-Mar Excel Non-Electric composting toilet stands out as the premier choice for off-grid enthusiasts.
Energy-Free Operation Benefits
The Sun-Mar Excel operates completely without electricity, making it perfect for cabins, hunting lodges, and off-grid homes. You’ll never worry about power outages affecting your bathroom facilities. This gravity-fed system uses natural evaporation and a patented bio-drum design to process waste efficiently. The absence of fans or heaters means zero energy consumption and greater reliability in remote settings.
Handling Capacity and Composting Efficiency
Capable of serving up to 3 people full-time or 6 people part-time, the Excel handles high usage remarkably well. Its three-chamber system separates fresh waste, composting matter, and finished compost for optimal decomposition. The innovative bio-drum can be rotated every few days to aerate the compost, accelerating breakdown and preventing odors. You’ll typically only need to empty the finished compost drawer every 3-4 weeks, making maintenance surprisingly manageable.
Separett Villa 9215: Best Urine-Diverting Model
The Separett Villa 9215 stands out as the premier urine-diverting composting toilet on the market, offering sophisticated technology in an elegant design. This Swedish-made model excels at separating liquid and solid waste efficiently, making it perfect for those seeking a low-maintenance composting solution.
Advanced Separation Technology
The Villa 9215 features an innovative urine diversion system that automatically separates liquids from solids at the source. Its specialized bowl design directs urine to a separate drain while solids fall into a biodegradable bag lined container. This prevents moisture buildup in the solids chamber, dramatically speeding up the composting process and eliminating the common wet, sludgy issues found in less sophisticated models.
Odor Control and Emptying Frequency
With its continuous ventilation system and effective separation technology, the Villa 9215 provides virtually odorless operation. The fan runs constantly on minimal electricity (just 10 watts), creating negative pressure that directs any potential odors outside through a vent pipe. You’ll only need to empty the solid waste container about every 3-4 weeks for a family of four, while the urine container requires more frequent attention depending on usage patterns and diversion setup.
BioLet Composting Toilet: Best Electric Model for Residential Use
Heating System and Acceleration Features
The BioLet composting toilet features an innovative electric heating system that significantly accelerates the decomposition process. Its thermostatically controlled heater maintains optimal temperatures of 65-70°F inside the composting chamber, breaking down waste up to 90% faster than non-electric models. You’ll appreciate the built-in evaporation system that effectively processes liquid waste, eliminating the need for separate containers. The automated mixing arms activate after each use, ensuring thorough aeration and preventing odors while maximizing decomposition efficiency.
Space Requirements and Ventilation Needs
The BioLet requires minimal installation space with dimensions of just 26″D × 21″W × 28″H, fitting comfortably in bathrooms of various sizes. You’ll need to place it against an exterior wall for proper ventilation, as it requires a 2-inch vent pipe that extends outside your home. Unlike some composting toilets, the BioLet doesn’t need a large basement area for installation—it’s entirely self-contained. The ventilation system creates negative pressure inside the unit, drawing air downward through the toilet to eliminate odors while supporting the aerobic decomposition process that’s essential for effective composting.
Air Head Dry Composting Toilet: Best for Marine and RV Applications
The Air Head Dry Composting Toilet has earned its reputation as the go-to solution for marine vessels and recreational vehicles where space and weight considerations are critical. This American-made composting toilet combines exceptional functionality with thoughtful design elements specifically tailored for life on the move.
Compact Design Benefits
The Air Head’s space-efficient dimensions (19″ height × 19″ depth × 13″ width) make it perfect for tight quarters in boats and RVs. You’ll appreciate how it fits neatly into small bathrooms without sacrificing comfort or functionality. Its lightweight construction (23 pounds empty) minimizes impact on vehicle weight limits while the front-mounted crank handle allows easy operation even in confined spaces.
Durability in Mobile Environments
Built specifically to withstand the rigors of travel, the Air Head features marine-grade stainless steel hardware and a robust polyethylene construction that resists corrosion in humid environments. The sealed design prevents leaks during transport over rough terrain or choppy waters. Its secure mounting system keeps the unit firmly in place through movement and vibration, ensuring reliable performance in constantly changing environments.
OGO Waterless Toilet: Best Budget-Friendly Option
The OGO Waterless Toilet stands out as an affordable entry point into the world of composting toilets without compromising on essential features or functionality.
Cost-Effective Features
The OGO Waterless Toilet delivers exceptional value at nearly half the price of premium models. Its simplified design uses a standard 5-gallon bucket system with biodegradable bags for waste collection, making maintenance straightforward and affordable. The toilet includes a comfortable seat comparable to standard household fixtures and a ventilation fan that effectively manages odors despite the budget-friendly price point.
Long-Term Savings Analysis
Investing in the OGO Waterless Toilet can save you approximately $230 annually on water bills compared to conventional toilets. The minimal replacement parts cost averages just $45 per year for biodegradable bags and composting medium. With its durable plastic construction designed to last 8-10 years, the OGO offers an impressive return on investment, typically paying for itself within the first 14 months through reduced utility expenses.
EcoJohn WC5: Best High-Capacity System for Multiple Users
The EcoJohn WC5 stands out as the premier solution for multi-user environments where high-capacity waste management is essential. This robust composting toilet system efficiently handles frequent use while maintaining exceptional water conservation standards.
Commercial Applications
The EcoJohn WC5 excels in commercial settings like campgrounds, parks, and eco-tourism facilities where traditional plumbing may be impractical. Its industrial-grade components can withstand up to 30 uses per day without performance degradation, making it ideal for visitor centers and remote workplaces. The system’s durable stainless steel construction ensures longevity even in high-traffic environments, reducing replacement costs and maintenance downtime.
Energy Consumption and Processing Power
Despite its impressive capacity, the EcoJohn WC5 operates with remarkable energy efficiency. The system consumes only 1.5 kWh per day when operating at full capacity, substantially less than comparable commercial models. Its proprietary combustion technology reaches temperatures of 1400°F, completely incinerating waste and eliminating pathogens without chemical additives. This powerful processing capability allows for a 95% volume reduction, minimizing emptying frequency even in continuous-use scenarios.
Installing Your Composting Toilet: Important Considerations Before Purchase
Choosing a composting toilet that fits your lifestyle is just the beginning of your water conservation journey. Before purchasing you’ll need to consider ventilation requirements installation space and local regulations. Whether you opt for the Nature’s Head for overall quality the Sun-Mar Excel for off-grid living or the budget-friendly OGO you’re making a significant environmental impact.
These modern systems can save thousands of gallons of water annually while creating valuable compost for your garden. The initial investment quickly pays for itself through reduced utility bills and maintenance costs.
By selecting from these top seven options you’re not just buying a toilet—you’re investing in sustainable living and contributing to water conservation efforts that benefit both your household and the planet for years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do composting toilets work?
Composting toilets work by separating liquid and solid waste, allowing natural decomposition through aerobic bacteria. Unlike traditional toilets, these systems store waste in a chamber where organic materials are added to aid decomposition and control odors. No water is used for flushing, and the waste gradually breaks down into nutrient-rich compost that can be safely used as fertilizer for non-edible plants.
How much water can I save with a composting toilet?
A typical household can save up to 4,000 gallons of water annually by switching to a composting toilet. Traditional toilets use several gallons per flush, while composting toilets require no water for waste disposal. This significant water conservation makes them ideal for environmentally conscious households, tiny homes, and off-grid living situations where water resources may be limited.
Do composting toilets smell bad?
When properly maintained, composting toilets produce minimal to no odor. Modern designs incorporate ventilation systems that create negative pressure to direct any potential odors outside. Regular addition of bulking materials like coconut coir or sawdust after each use helps absorb moisture and prevent smells. Most high-quality models feature continuous ventilation systems that keep the bathroom environment fresh and odor-free.
How often do you need to empty a composting toilet?
Emptying frequency varies by model and usage. For solid waste, most residential models require emptying every 3-4 weeks for a family of four. Liquid containers typically need more frequent attention, sometimes every few days depending on usage. High-capacity systems like the EcoJohn WC5 can handle up to 30 uses per day with minimal emptying due to waste incineration technology.
Can composting toilets be used in any home?
Yes, composting toilets can be installed in most homes, though some considerations apply. They require proper ventilation, typically through a small vent pipe to the outside. While some models need electricity, others like the Sun-Mar Excel operate completely off-grid. Space requirements vary, with compact options available for small bathrooms. Building codes regarding composting toilets vary by location, so checking local regulations is recommended.
What’s the best composting toilet for beginners?
The OGO Waterless Toilet is ideal for beginners due to its affordable price point, simple maintenance, and straightforward design. It uses a standard 5-gallon bucket system with biodegradable bags, making waste disposal uncomplicated. The system requires minimal technical knowledge to install and maintain, and its cost-effectiveness (paying for itself within 14 months through water savings) makes it an excellent entry point for those new to composting toilets.
How much do composting toilets cost?
Composting toilet prices range from budget-friendly options like the OGO Waterless Toilet (approximately $200-400) to more advanced systems like the BioLet electric model or the EcoJohn WC5 that can cost $1,500-3,000. Mid-range options like Nature’s Head and Air Head typically fall between $900-1,200. While initial costs exceed traditional toilets, the investment is often recovered through water bill savings within 1-3 years.
Is the compost from these toilets safe to use?
Yes, when properly processed, the compost is safe for use on ornamental plants, trees, and shrubs. Most manufacturers recommend using the compost only on non-edible plants. The decomposition process, when complete, eliminates pathogens through heat and time. Different jurisdictions have varying regulations about humanure usage, so it’s important to check local guidelines before applying compost from your toilet to your garden.
