5 Best Water Heaters for Small Spaces: Traditional vs Tankless – Save Without Sacrifice

Finding the perfect water heater for your compact living space can feel like solving a complex puzzle. You’re balancing size constraints with the need for reliable hot water, all while trying to keep energy costs manageable. Whether you’re renovating a tiny apartment, outfitting a cabin, or maximizing your laundry room’s efficiency, the right water heater makes all the difference.

Traditional tank models and modern tankless systems each offer distinct advantages for small spaces. Tankless options eliminate the bulky storage tank but come with different installation requirements, while compact traditional heaters provide familiarity at a lower upfront cost. We’ve researched and compared the top contenders in both categories to help you make the best choice for your specific space limitations and hot water needs.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What to Consider Before Buying a Small Space Water Heater

When you’re working with limited square footage, selecting the right water heater becomes crucial for both comfort and efficiency. Before investing in a compact water heating solution, you’ll need to evaluate several key factors that impact performance and installation.

Space Requirements and Installation Constraints

The available space will significantly dictate your water heater options. Measure your designated area precisely—height, width, and depth—before shopping. Traditional tank heaters require floor space and vertical clearance, while tankless models can mount on walls, fitting into closets, under sinks, or even in outdoor cabinets. Consider access points for water lines, venting requirements, and maintenance clearance to avoid costly modifications later.

Energy Efficiency and Utility Costs

Energy efficiency ratings directly impact your monthly bills and environmental footprint. Tankless heaters typically achieve higher efficiency ratings (0.82-0.98 UEF) than tank models (0.60-0.80 UEF), potentially saving 24-34% on energy costs. However, initial installation costs are higher for tankless systems. Evaluate fuel availability too—gas models generally cost less to operate than electric ones but require proper ventilation and gas lines.

Hot Water Demand for Your Household

Your household’s specific hot water needs should guide your selection process. Calculate your peak usage—when multiple fixtures might run simultaneously. For one person, a small tank (20-30 gallons) or low-capacity tankless unit may suffice. Larger households need either a high-capacity tankless system (measured in GPM—gallons per minute) or a properly sized tank model. Consider usage patterns: frequent short draws favor tank heaters, while longer continuous usage benefits from tankless models.

Traditional Tank Water Heaters for Compact Areas

Despite the growing popularity of tankless models, traditional tank water heaters still offer practical solutions for small spaces when chosen correctly. These compact versions deliver reliable hot water while taking up minimal room in tight quarters.

Best Compact Traditional Option: Rheem Performance 20-Gallon Electric

The Rheem Performance 20-Gallon Electric water heater stands out as an ideal solution for small apartments and tiny homes. At just 21.5 inches in diameter and 31.5 inches tall, it fits neatly in closets or utility corners while providing enough hot water for 1-2 person households. Its fast recovery rate of 21 gallons per hour and 6-year warranty make it both practical and reliable for daily use.

Best Budget-Friendly Choice: A.O. Smith Signature 19-Gallon Electric

The A.O. Smith Signature 19-Gallon Electric water heater delivers exceptional value without sacrificing quality in tight spaces. Priced typically under $400, it features durable components including a commercial-grade anode rod that extends tank life. Its compact 18-inch diameter design fits perfectly in small closets while still providing sufficient hot water for a single person or couple’s daily needs.

Tankless Water Heaters for Maximum Space Savings

Tankless water heaters represent the ultimate space-saving solution for compact living arrangements, offering on-demand hot water without the bulky storage tank that traditional models require.

Best Overall Tankless Model: Rinnai V65iN Natural Gas Tankless

The Rinnai V65iN delivers exceptional performance in a wall-mounted package that’s just 14 inches tall. This natural gas unit provides 6.5 GPM flow rate—enough for simultaneous showers in compact homes. With Energy Star certification and a 12-year heat exchanger warranty, it offers reliability and efficiency that justifies its $700-900 price point for long-term space-conscious homeowners.

Best Electric Tankless Heater: EcoSmart ECO 11 Electric Tankless

The EcoSmart ECO 11 measures a mere 11.5″ × 8″ × 3.75″, making it perfect for ultra-tight spaces like closets or under sinks. This electric model heats water to 105°F at 2.0 GPM, ideal for single bathroom apartments or tiny homes. Its digital temperature control adjusts in 1-degree increments, providing precise comfort while its self-modulating technology helps minimize energy consumption during periods of lower demand.

Best Premium Option: Stiebel Eltron Tempra 24 Plus Electric Tankless

The Stiebel Eltron Tempra 24 Plus represents German engineering excellence in a sleek 16.6″ × 14.5″ × 4.6″ package. This premium electric unit maintains consistent water temperatures regardless of demand fluctuations through its Advanced Flow Control technology. With whisper-quiet operation and 4.5 GPM capacity, it’s perfect for luxury small apartments where both space and performance are non-negotiable priorities.

Installation Tips for Small Space Water Heaters

DIY vs. Professional Installation Considerations

While DIY installation can save money, professional installation offers crucial benefits for small spaces. Licensed plumbers ensure proper venting, gas line connections, and electrical requirements are met safely. Tankless units generally require professional installation due to their specialized electrical or gas requirements. Traditional tank models may be more DIY-friendly, but incorrect installation can void warranties and create safety hazards. Always check local building codes before deciding between DIY and professional help.

Creative Mounting Solutions to Maximize Space

Wall-mounted tankless units free up valuable floor space in small areas. Consider recessed installation between wall studs to create an even more streamlined profile. For traditional tank models, explore corner placement options or dedicated closets with proper ventilation. Multi-purpose solutions like under-sink installations work well in tiny homes or apartments. Some compact tanks can be installed horizontally in crawl spaces or attics with proper insulation. Always ensure your mounting solution maintains required clearances for safety and service access.

Maintaining Your Small Space Water Heater

Routine Maintenance Requirements for Each Type

Traditional tank water heaters require annual flushing to remove sediment buildup that reduces efficiency and shortens lifespan. Check the pressure relief valve every six months by lifting the lever and ensuring water flows freely. For tankless models, descale every 6-12 months using a vinegar solution and flush kit, especially in hard water areas. Both types need anode rod inspections—tank heaters every 2 years and tankless units during descaling sessions.

Extending the Lifespan of Your Water Heater

Install a water softener if you have hard water to prevent mineral buildup that damages heating elements. Set your water temperature to 120°F to reduce stress on components while still providing sanitary hot water. For tank models, drain a gallon monthly to remove sediment from the bottom. Consider professional maintenance every two years to catch potential issues before they cause system failure. Tankless owners should clean intake filters quarterly to maintain optimal performance.

Final Verdict: Choosing Between Traditional and Tankless for Small Spaces

Selecting the perfect water heater for your small space ultimately comes down to your specific needs. Traditional tank models like the Rheem Performance 20-Gallon and A.O. Smith Signature 19-Gallon offer reliable solutions at budget-friendly prices when space isn’t extremely limited.

For ultra-compact areas the Rinnai V65iN tankless system delivers exceptional performance while the EcoSmart ECO 11 and Stiebel Eltron Tempra 24 Plus provide space-saving alternatives with different features and price points.

Remember to consider your installation options maintenance requirements and long-term energy costs. Whether you choose traditional or tankless measuring your space calculating your hot water needs and understanding efficiency ratings will ensure you’ll enjoy reliable hot water without sacrificing your valuable square footage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key considerations when choosing a water heater for small spaces?

When selecting a water heater for compact areas, focus on three critical factors: space requirements, energy efficiency, and hot water demand. Measure your installation area carefully, understand energy efficiency ratings (look for Energy Star certification), and calculate your household’s peak hot water usage. These considerations will help you balance physical constraints with performance needs to find the perfect small-space solution.

How do tankless water heaters compare to traditional tanks for small spaces?

Tankless water heaters offer maximum space savings by eliminating the storage tank and providing hot water on demand. They mount on walls to free up floor space but typically cost more upfront. Traditional tank models take up more room but are generally less expensive and simpler to install. For extremely limited spaces, tankless models usually provide the best space-efficient solution while maintaining adequate hot water supply.

What is the best traditional tank water heater for small apartments?

The Rheem Performance 20-Gallon Electric water heater stands out as the top compact traditional option for small apartments and tiny homes. Despite its reduced size, it offers a fast recovery rate and comes with a solid warranty. Its slim profile allows it to fit in tight spaces while still providing sufficient hot water for small households.

Can I install a small space water heater myself?

While DIY installation is possible for some models (especially electric tank heaters), professional installation is recommended, particularly for tankless units. Tankless systems often require specialized electrical work, ventilation, or gas line modifications that should be handled by qualified professionals. DIY installation may save money initially but risks safety issues and potential code violations that could cost more in the long run.

How often should small space water heaters be maintained?

Traditional tank models require annual flushing to remove sediment buildup and anode rod inspection every 1-2 years. Tankless units need descaling every 6-12 months, particularly in hard water areas. Regular maintenance extends lifespan, maintains efficiency, and prevents costly repairs. Consider professional service annually, and follow manufacturer-specific guidelines for your model to ensure optimal performance.

What is the best tankless water heater for ultra-tight spaces?

The EcoSmart ECO 11 Electric Tankless water heater is ideal for ultra-tight spaces. Its compact design (11.5″ × 8″ × 3.75″) makes it perfect for tiny apartments, RVs, or small cabins. It provides sufficient hot water for one bathroom homes while requiring minimal installation space. This unit offers on-demand heating with 99.8% energy efficiency, making it both space and energy efficient.

How can I maximize space when installing a water heater?

Get creative with mounting options: install tankless units on walls, consider recessed installations between studs, or explore multi-purpose placements like under-sink units. For traditional tanks, utilize corner spaces or dedicated closets. Ensure all installations maintain required clearances for safety and service access. Some compact models can even be installed horizontally in crawl spaces or attics to free up living area.

Do small water heaters cost less to operate than standard models?

Not necessarily. Operating costs depend more on energy efficiency ratings than size. While compact traditional tanks may use less energy to heat smaller volumes of water, their insulation might be less effective. Tankless models typically offer better long-term energy savings regardless of size, with potential utility bill reductions of 25-40%. Always check the annual operating cost estimate on the EnergyGuide label when comparing options.